Makueni under Kibwana

Kivutha Kibwana's tenure as Governor of Makueni County (2013-2022) represented a distinctive approach to county governance, emphasizing transparency, health service expansion, and food security initiatives. Makueni under Kibwana became cited internationally as a model for effective devolved governance in Kenya.

The Kibwana Governance Model

Kibwana, a constitutional law professor from the University of Nairobi with prior experience as Member of Parliament and cabinet minister, brought academic training in governance and human rights to county leadership. His model emphasized:

Transparency and Accountability: Public disclosure of county budgets, expenditures, and decision-making processes.
Evidence-Based Policy: Reliance on data and research rather than political patronage in setting priorities.
Inclusive Governance: Engagement with community stakeholders and civil society in policy formulation.
Service Delivery Focus: Emphasis on providing health, education, and water services rather than political spoils.

Universal Health Coverage

Kibwana's signature initiative was establishing universal health coverage (UHC) for Makueni residents. This policy made government hospital services free or heavily subsidized for all county residents, eliminating user fees that had previously prevented poor households from accessing healthcare.

The UHC implementation involved:

Facility Expansion: Construction and upgrading of health facilities across the county.
Staff Recruitment: Hiring of health workers to staff expanded facilities.
Equipment and Supplies: Investment in medical equipment and pharmaceutical supplies.
Integration with National System: Integration of county health services with Kenya's national health system.

The UHC policy resulted in dramatically increased hospital utilization, with health facility attendance rising substantially. This raised both positive outcomes (more people receiving healthcare) and challenges (facility overcrowding, supply constraints).

Food and Nutrition Security Initiative

Kibwana established a county food and nutrition security policy addressing chronic food insecurity in Makueni's semi-arid environment. The policy included:

Food Reserves: Establishing strategic food reserves managed at county level.
Nutrition Programs: School feeding programs and targeted nutritional support for vulnerable populations.
Agricultural Development: Support for improved farming methods and crop diversification.
Water Development: Investment in water harvesting and irrigation to expand productive agricultural land.

The food security initiative acknowledged that market-based food systems had not ensured adequate nutrition for poorer households, requiring targeted policy intervention.

Transparent Procurement

Kibwana emphasized transparent and competitive procurement processes for county contracts and supplies. Traditional approaches to government procurement had involved substantial corruption, with contracts allocated through patronage networks. Transparent bidding and procurement oversight aimed to reduce corruption and ensure value for money.

The transparent procurement approach faced resistance from political and business networks benefiting from previous corrupt systems. However, the policy contributed to improved donor and international agency perception of Makueni governance.

International Recognition and Academic Interest

The Kibwana governance model attracted international attention and academic study. International development organizations, research institutions, and academic scholars studied Makueni as a potential model for effective county governance. The county became a site for governance research and learning exchanges with other counties and countries.

This international recognition elevated Kibwana's profile beyond Kenya, with invitations to present Makueni's governance approach at international forums.

Challenges and Limitations

Despite achievements, the Kibwana governance model faced significant constraints:

Limited County Resources: Makueni County's revenue base was limited, constraining the scale of service provision possible. The UHC program required substantial financial commitment that sometimes exceeded county capacity.
Development Gaps: Makueni's economic base in semi-arid agriculture limited job creation and income generation, constraining both household capacity to contribute to health and food security and broader development outcomes.
National System Integration: The interaction between county governance and national systems (particularly ministry of health and agricultural extension) sometimes created tensions or duplicative efforts.
Political Resistance: The emphasis on merit-based governance and transparent processes created conflict with political networks benefiting from previous patronage approaches.

Decision Not to Seek Third Term

In 2022, Kibwana chose not to seek a third gubernatorial term, though he could constitutionally have done so. His reasons for this decision included:

Governance Transition: Belief that leadership should rotate and avoid concentration of power.
Academic Return: Possible desire to return to academic work and intellectual pursuits.
Platform Shift: Shift toward national political involvement rather than county governance.

His successor, Ali Mwanthi, took office in 2022, beginning a transition from the Kibwana model.

Legacy and Influence

The Kibwana governance model established standards for county governance transparency and service delivery that influenced other county governments. Other governors subsequently adopted some transparency and service-delivery-focused approaches partly in response to Kibwana's example.

However, the sustainability of Kibwana's initiatives under different leadership remained uncertain. Changes in county leadership and priorities sometimes led to reduction of service commitments Kibwana had established.

Our Kenya

Explorer